e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyeliner & Shadow Stick - Reviews | MakeupAlley (2025)

5.0

from

LokaLopez13

11 years ago

I love this! It last all day and the colors are great best part about it was it was only $1 at dollar tree!

About reviewer (53 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinOily, Fair-Medium

HairBrunette

EyesBrown

4.0

from

lsinnes

12 years ago

I really can't believe all of the negative reviews on here about this eyeliner duo. I really like both sides of it. I've used it for about two weeks straight and I haven't had any issues with it...

About reviewer (1 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinCombination, Fair-Medium

HairBrunette

EyesBrown

4.0

from

colleenkelley

12 years ago

First of all, I have to say that I cannot STAND when people give a product a negative review because the color on their computer screen didn't match the color of the item they got. Listen up,...

About reviewer (7 reviews)

Age30-35

SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Warm

HairBrown, Wavy, Fine

EyesBrown

3.0

from

MissCarley

12 years ago

I bought this to use on mornings when I'm short on time... I really like the idea of multiuse products. The shadow stick isn't anything to write home about, I found the consistency really hard and...

About reviewer (53 reviews)

Age

SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium, Not Sure

HairBrunette, Wavy, Medium

EyesBlue

1.0

from

MissMerryMakeup

12 years ago

Was so excited to try this product! But it turned out to simply be smudge city. The shadow stick was (in my eyes) streaky and creased almost instantly. While the eyeliner had nice color payoff it...

5.0

from

Ispania

12 years ago

Wow! I am impressed! Why? Because it is only 3$, but it delivers as much as more expensive products do.I may sound raving. It's not like they invented smth new. But the quality and price...

About reviewer (113 reviews)

Age30-35

SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Not Sure

HairBrown, Wavy, Medium

EyesBrown

4.0

from

sayshal

13 years ago

I bought this not realizing this was an eyeliner and a cream shadow. I bought it for the eyeliner which goes on smooth and looks fantastic. Since I got it in black/smoke I don't find the shadow...

About reviewer (50 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinSensitive, Fair, Warm

HairBrunette, Straight, Medium

EyesBrown

1.0

from

laura23kfp

13 years ago

Really liked this when it first went on but it started smudging within hours. I also used the E.L.F. eye primer before hand and it still creased and smudged.

About reviewer (2 reviews)

Age25-29

SkinCombination, Fair

HairBrunette

EyesGreen

1.0

from

lauren93

13 years ago

I haven't worst eyeliner ever! Never more!

About reviewer (29 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinNormal, Medium

HairBrunette

EyesGray

5.0

from

Reservechic

13 years ago

I own this in Pearl/Glow and Black/Smoke. I especially love using the Glow cream eye color for highlighting underneath my eyebrows with. And, I am a huge fan of using the Pearl liner to line my...

About reviewer (972 reviews)

Age36-43

SkinSensitive, Medium

HairBlack

EyesBlack

4.0

from

kimberlygrace

13 years ago

I bought this product in black/smoke a month or two ago, & I actually really like it. The eyeliner part does smear sometimes, but I found if you use the liner, & then go over it with the shadow, it...

About reviewer (9 reviews)

AgeUnder 18

SkinNormal, Medium, Not Sure

HairBlack, Other, Other

EyesBrown

3.0

from

ANZology

13 years ago

I am writing this review for the shade moss/green, because I have a problem with the colors as they are in the ad vs. the actual product. The product itself is nice. I love, love, looove that it's...

About reviewer (79 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinCombination, Fair, Neutral

HairRed, Wavy, Medium

EyesBrown

5.0

from

paranoiaa

13 years ago

Hum. I just got this product recently in brown/basic, and I really don't get the low ratings... because I REALLY LIKE IT! The liner side is a dark brown/gold colour and the shadow side is a...

About reviewer (31 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Cool

HairBrunette, Straight, Fine

EyesBrown

4.0

from

breakawaysue

13 years ago

I bought the basic/brown combo. I have a terrible time getting eyeliner to look good on me, and this is no different. That being said, I do really like the shadow end. The color comes out more...

About reviewer (23 reviews)

Age36-43

SkinCombination, Fair-Medium

HairBlond

EyesGreen

5.0

from

MrsTefee

13 years ago

I dont know why this gets such bad reviews because I LOVE this product. The eyeliner/shadows are very creamy and easy to put on. I bought this in pearl glow and its amazing with my bright blue...

About reviewer (276 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinCombination, Fair, Warm

HairBlond, Straight, Fine

EyesBlue

2.0

from

EsmeT

13 years ago

I bought this in black/charcoal and loved the concept, however the product is pretty much useless in real life. The shadow end (charcoal) is a lovely colour but too greasy to get an ever layer of,...

About reviewer (5 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinSensitive, Fair-Medium, Warm

HairBrunette, Straight, Medium

EyesHazel

1.0

from

WarmSocks

13 years ago

This stuff sucks.The liner smudges all around my eyes, no matter what. And the shadow stick isn't pigmented at all.Both are too greasy, and neither of the caps would stay on.

About reviewer (57 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinCombination, Fair, Cool

HairOther, Straight, Fine

EyesHazel

1.0

from

Jandie

13 years ago

I bought this in purple/plum and really don't like it. The eyeliner is waxy and the eyeshadow part is too creamy. Neither stays on. I buy a lot of E.L.F. products, but I would not buy this one again.

About reviewer (23 reviews)

Age36-43

SkinCombination, Fair

HairBlond

EyesGreen

2.0

from

NikitaRose

13 years ago

I have this in midnight/blue (although you can hardly call it ''blue'' it is a dark greysih color with a hint of blue) and brown color. I really wanted to like this because I love the idea but it's...

About reviewer (526 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinDry, Fair, Cool

HairBlond, Straight, Medium

EyesGray

2.0

from

Iphy

14 years ago

I hadn't tried ELF makeup before this purchase, just their brushes, which I love for the price. I bought this duo in bloom/pearl and do not much like it. Haven't used it as an eye shadow base, but...

About reviewer (130 reviews)

Age19-24

SkinDry, Fair, Cool

HairBrown, Curly, Fine

EyesGreen

e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyeliner & Shadow Stick - Reviews | MakeupAlley (2025)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Van Hayes

Last Updated:

Views: 6607

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Van Hayes

Birthday: 1994-06-07

Address: 2004 Kling Rapid, New Destiny, MT 64658-2367

Phone: +512425013758

Job: National Farming Director

Hobby: Reading, Polo, Genealogy, amateur radio, Scouting, Stand-up comedy, Cryptography

Introduction: My name is Van Hayes, I am a thankful, friendly, smiling, calm, powerful, fine, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.